No discussions yet. Join BookLovers to start a discussion about this book!
If “Haints Stay” is a response to “Sisters Brothers”, it surpasses its predecessor handily. It is more serious, more profound, and far more satisfying at the end. It’s as if Winnette challenged himself to build a book around a humorous reinterpretation of the previous book’s title. Both are about a pair of gunslinging assassins (“sisters brothers” indeed); both describe wild, painful journeys through the early American west; both use clear, elegant, descriptive prose—sparse yet poetic—and both upend the tradition of the western novel in more ways than one. (And one of Winnette’s brothers is even similar in spirit to one of deWitt’s). But the arc of “Haints Stay” is more serious, its message more deep. Upon re-reading “Sisters Brothers”, I realized with disappointment that the book is quite shallow. It's an interesting story, filled with lightness, humor, colorful characters, and compelling anecdotes, but never took me any closer to a deeper understanding of the characters, the world they inhabit, or the world I do. “Haints Stay”, on the other hand, forced me to confront a lot of unpleasant information; it forced me to think about what was meant by the devastating, concluding sentence of the book—the final, foreboding image of the novel. What did it explain about the past? What did it foretell of the future? There's no answer. No interpretation of the book can demonstrate that any evidence leads to any definite conclusion. We're left in the middle of things, forced to consider what we think could (or should) happen, or more interestingly, to wish had never happened. We realize that the ending is the inevitable outcropping of all the events which came before—all those awful, painful, horrible things that happened before—all those things that left an imprint on the actors. Some reviewers here have said that the story falls apart midway, when the brothers and their young friend split up, the three plot threads becoming independent of each other, but I disagree strong...
No quotes shared yet. Join BookLovers to share your favorite quotes!
More by Colin Winnette
View AllSimilar Books in Literature & Fiction
View All Similar